Dynamics ignored after crescendo. MacOS High Sierra Version 3.4.1.25011
In this piece, bar 34 and 35 are supposed to have a crescendo to ƒ that starts at bar 36. Bar 37 is supposed to go back to p, but doesn't as long as the crescendo lines are present.
if I remove the cresc... lines, the ƒ and p dynamics are followed as expected.
When added again, the p is ignored. This applies for both "cresc..." and the hairpin.
OS: macOS High Sierra (10.13), Arch.: x86_64, MuseScore version (64-bit): 3.4.1.25011, revision: 20414b2
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| L'Apprenti_Sorcier-orch.mscz | 34.39 KB |
| L'Apprenti_Sorcier-fail.mscz | 34.56 KB |
Comments
I'm on W10 with the same version of MuseScore and the HQ sound font. Hair pins for measures 34 and 35 work. But it is very subtle. As a test on your system, change the "p" in measure 33 to "pp" and the "f" in measure 36 to "ff". See if hairpins work then.
Personally, I've never used "cresc.". Did you look at how it is defined in the Inspector?
In reply to I'm on W10 with the same… by bobjp
And the final "p" worked for me also.
In reply to And the final "p" worked for… by bobjp
The hairpins work; it's not a big/quick change. Just that the ending p doesn't work with the hairpin/cresc. in, so it played right through to the end as ƒ.
However, I see there's lots of new issues on this release; I expect there'll be a new one soon.
In reply to The hairpins work; it's not… by nevin.williams…
Yes; The last "p" has no effect.
I deleted it and put it again, the loudness still remains at "f".
I tried it with a non-expressive soundfont. (Of course I adjusted the synthesizer accordingly)
in this way "p" works.
Win10
Somehow it's connected also to the ottava marking - it's fixed if I delete that, or just end it before the measures in question. My guess there is some internal confusion over which octave to apply the dynamics to somehow, not that this really makes sense.