default dotted quarter note in 6/8, 9/8, 12/8, etc

• Aug 12, 2016 - 23:01

Whenever working in a... ternary?... time signature, I have to clean up rests to look as they should - dotted quarters instead of quarter + eighth. I've also hit N and started typing a couple of times, only to realize that I needed to add the dot to get the result I was looking for.

I'm not sure changing the default from quarter to dotted quarter on those kinds of time signatures is possible, but it would be nice.


Comments

Do you mean just a different default duration selected when entering note input mode, or something else? If you mean what I think you might mean, it's possible shoogle's real-time MIDI project will yield a function to intelligently combine smaller durations (like a quarter rest and an eighth rest) into larger ones (like a dotted eighth rest) according to the time signature. But that would be an after-the-fact command you would run on rhythms already entered.

P.S. Compound.

I could imagien the default duration on entry to note input mode being made dotted quarter, but frankly, I wouldn't like that. If it's to change, I'd prefer it be whatever the denominator is - 8 in 6/8 time, etc. Or, as requested elsewhere, to keep whatever it is curre4ntly selected in the cases where it doesn't currently. Mostly, though, I think people should just be in the habit of entering the initial duration themselves, just as they do for all other notes. Whatever we guess is likely to be wrong often enough that I can't imagine why anyone would want to depend on it.

But I can also imagine wanting rests to be create properly accoridng to standard compound meter conventions while entering notes. That's an open feature request - see #4867: Rests in measures should be grouped according to time signature

In reply to by Marc Sabatella

I wouldn't mind default eighth notes, but then I would want everything to be default duration of an eighth note.

It's not about depending on it, it's that a habit is developed of 'oh hey, default is one beat, I don't need to worry about setting length if it's one beat', and then that habit gets confuddled in compound time. Eighth notes everywhere solves it, as does switching to dotted quarter. I'm just looking for consistency.

I'm glad rests are being worked on!

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.