[MusicXML] Import and export of nested tuplet does not work

• Dec 21, 2011 - 12:45
Type
Functional
Severity
S4 - Minor
Status
active
Project
Tags

Neither import nor export works correctly. This applies to the 0.9.6 branch as well as to the trunk.


Comments

I confirm that this is an important issue for MusicXml exports.
It is not possible to distinguish correctly between nested tuplets at present, either in v1.3 or 2.0 (current nightly build).

As this issue has not been looked at for over a year, here is a status -
v2.0.2 still gives wrong musicxml output.
The attached test file "nested-tuplets", when exported to musicxml, will produce an irrelevant backup node. This confuses everything, especially when importing (v2.0.2 gives an error message to this effect).

Attachment Size
nested-tuplets.mscz 2.81 KB
nested-tuplets.xml 5.31 KB

Status is unchanged because no work has been done on this issue. As it seems nested tuples are seldom used, it simply never reached the top of my todo list. Feel free to solve it yourself if it is important to you. I am perfectly willing to solve this sometime, but cannot commit to a delivery date, as long as higher priority issues keep popping up.