I just tried it with 133dde1 (win7) fluid.sf3 and it is still wrong. The audio produced is as if the 9ths weren't tied. The 5ths play correctly. This example works correctly in 1.3.
The file is broken in the first place. There is no time signature and most importantly, the second measure on the left hand doesn't add up to 4 beats. I guess a tuplet has been forgotten on the first group of notes.
I close this issue. Reopen needed.
Attached is the simplest example I can create that shows the problem. The figure with quintuplets sounds almost identical to the figure with septuplets in 1.3. In 2.0 the septuplets produce three separate tones, as if the septuplets are not tied.
Some tuplet groups created in 1.3 result in a corrupted score when opened in 2.0
The problem is not Audio related at all - it is a corruption of the score.....
The actual time signature of the third bar of Ragtime Nightingale is showing as 479/4 in MuseScore 2.0 commit bc04561
Clicking on bar 4 crashes MuseScore 2.0
Opening the score in 1.3 shows none of this behaviour
It seems obvious then that the problem is related to the opening of scores made in1.3 in 2.0, with specific reference to some tuplet figures corrupting the score.
Title changed accordingly.
EDIT: Just checked the other 2 files and it is the same problem. the measures not playing back properly in CS are showing actual time signatures of 959/4 and 961/4 in 2.0 and the single tuplet measure in the test piece is showing as 1921/4. This is not the case in 1.3
The problem is not just with an import from 1.3. If you create the test shown above (#8) in 2.0, save it and reload it into 2.0, the same problem occurs.
I'm sorry that this is not on point, but I need some help with ties.When I insert a tie from note to note in my already-written piece, two things happen:
1. The lyrics under the notes disappear.
2. The second note changes to duplicate the note it's tied to.
@CRE: you're at the wrong place here, this issue is totally unrelated and you should better go to the support forum.
Other than that: you probably want a slur rather than a tie
Comments
How corrupted? Which synthesizer are you using? Which soundfont?
It plays just fine for me in 133dde13a0 using fluid.sf3 soundfont.
The audio for the tied 9ths was not honored; the tied 5ths were. I used the fluid.sf3 Yamaha font.
I just tried it with 133dde1 (win7) fluid.sf3 and it is still wrong. The audio produced is as if the 9ths weren't tied. The 5ths play correctly. This example works correctly in 1.3.
if you remove the incorrect ties and put them back, the notes will play correctly, but if you then save and reload, they are incorrect again.
Did this score originate in 1.3?
The file is broken in the first place. There is no time signature and most importantly, the second measure on the left hand doesn't add up to 4 beats. I guess a tuplet has been forgotten on the first group of notes.
I close this issue. Reopen needed.
Here's another example of the problem. This one works in 1.3 and fails in 2.0
Attached is the simplest example I can create that shows the problem. The figure with quintuplets sounds almost identical to the figure with septuplets in 1.3. In 2.0 the septuplets produce three separate tones, as if the septuplets are not tied.
The problem is not Audio related at all - it is a corruption of the score.....
The actual time signature of the third bar of Ragtime Nightingale is showing as 479/4 in MuseScore 2.0 commit bc04561
Clicking on bar 4 crashes MuseScore 2.0
Opening the score in 1.3 shows none of this behaviour
It seems obvious then that the problem is related to the opening of scores made in1.3 in 2.0, with specific reference to some tuplet figures corrupting the score.
Title changed accordingly.
EDIT: Just checked the other 2 files and it is the same problem. the measures not playing back properly in CS are showing actual time signatures of 959/4 and 961/4 in 2.0 and the single tuplet measure in the test piece is showing as 1921/4. This is not the case in 1.3
PS I'm on Windows 8 Pro
The problem is not just with an import from 1.3. If you create the test shown above (#8) in 2.0, save it and reload it into 2.0, the same problem occurs.
Confirmed on Windows 8 MuseScore 2 commit 81308f5
Title changed to reflect current status.
Can someone try to reproduce on Mac and Linux?
Should status be changed to critical? It is resulting in loss of data.
I'm sorry that this is not on point, but I need some help with ties.When I insert a tie from note to note in my already-written piece, two things happen:
1. The lyrics under the notes disappear.
2. The second note changes to duplicate the note it's tied to.
Can someone help me out? Thanks very much.
@CRE: you're at the wrong place here, this issue is totally unrelated and you should better go to the support forum.
Other than that: you probably want a slur rather than a tie
Fixed in e929ed2f60
It's hopefully fixed. Please test further.
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.