[Guitar Pro] Drum notes incorrectly mapped
1. Open attached file.
Expected result: The cross notehead is mapped to 'G' - as seen in Harmony Assistant 9.6.3f and Guitar Pro 5.1.0 for iOS.
Actual Result: The cross notehead is mapped to 'A'.
Note: The file was taken from a complete score and edited in TuxGuitar 1.2.
Discussion: I don't understand TuxGuitar's representation - the notes appear almost two octaves below. The expected result will probably be correct?
Using MuseScore 2.0 Nightly Build (d5997be) - Mac 10.7.5.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Drum notes incorrectly mapped.gp4 | 1.03 KB |
| Drum notes incorrectly mapped.png | 25.89 KB |
Comments
Could you provide a complete drumset suitable to import GP files?
I've no idea.
How would this be done?
Create a score in GP/TG with quarter notes, one per drum instrument (128?). Create a text file and for each note, write down the MIDI pitch, the notehead shape, the staff line. I hope there is a default notehead etc... for drums.
From this text file, we could derive a default drumset that we can use for guitar pro import. Currently I believe we are using the default drumset of MuseScore and some MIDI pitches are not mapped, or mapped wrongly.
Using TuxGuitar 1.2, I created TG and GP5 files with all the notes in the 'Show Piano' keyboard.
we are using the default drumset of MuseScore and some MIDI pitches are not mapped, or mapped wrongly.
Is this something I should look at?
And is there an issue filed?
@ChurchOrganist No I don't think it's an issue per se. We need a default anyway. For percussion instrument, the drumset is overriden by instruments.xml. But we need a default drumset for import if the imported format doesn't define one, or instruments.xml doesn't define one. The default drumset is hardcoded https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/blob/master/libmscore/drumset.cp…
Fixed in fcd9b1b6006368698a3ea994e2fbe4bfbe63a101.
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.