Comment threading broken in Issue Tracker mirabilos • Feb 17, 2019 - 23:44 Reported version 3.0 Type musescore.org Frequency Once Severity S4 - Minor Reproducibility Always Status by design Regression No Workaround No Project MuseScore When I click “Reply” to a comment, mine still gets appended at the very end, breaking threading. In Forums, this works. Reply Comments Jojo-Schmitz • Feb 18, 2019 - 07:14 This is by design AFAIK, the differences between the issue tracker and forum topics Reply Thomas • Feb 18, 2019 - 07:57 Status active ⇒ by design This is indeed by design. Advised is to @ mention someone in the comment. Reply mirabilos • Feb 18, 2019 - 14:12 In reply to This is indeed by design… by Thomas Hm, this doesn’t help though when that person has written numerous posts and replying to some of them specifically. Reply mirabilos • Feb 18, 2019 - 14:12 Also, maybe then it would be best to disable the “Reply” below each comment, and just have the form at the bottom. Reply mike320 • Feb 18, 2019 - 15:48 Reply does seem to be redundant in the issue tracker. Reply Thomas • Feb 19, 2019 - 20:07 We could change the hyperlink of each reply with an anchor link to the comment textarea and prefill the area with the @ username. So a sort of shortcut to answer someone. Reply
Jojo-Schmitz • Feb 18, 2019 - 07:14 This is by design AFAIK, the differences between the issue tracker and forum topics Reply
Thomas • Feb 18, 2019 - 07:57 Status active ⇒ by design This is indeed by design. Advised is to @ mention someone in the comment. Reply
mirabilos • Feb 18, 2019 - 14:12 In reply to This is indeed by design… by Thomas Hm, this doesn’t help though when that person has written numerous posts and replying to some of them specifically. Reply
mirabilos • Feb 18, 2019 - 14:12 Also, maybe then it would be best to disable the “Reply” below each comment, and just have the form at the bottom. Reply
Thomas • Feb 19, 2019 - 20:07 We could change the hyperlink of each reply with an anchor link to the comment textarea and prefill the area with the @ username. So a sort of shortcut to answer someone. Reply
Comments
This is by design AFAIK, the differences between the issue tracker and forum topics
This is indeed by design. Advised is to @ mention someone in the comment.
In reply to This is indeed by design… by Thomas
Hm, this doesn’t help though when that person has written numerous posts and replying to some of them specifically.
Also, maybe then it would be best to disable the “Reply” below each comment, and just have the form at the bottom.
Reply does seem to be redundant in the issue tracker.
We could change the hyperlink of each reply with an anchor link to the comment textarea and prefill the area with the @ username. So a sort of shortcut to answer someone.