Key signatures do not include natural signs if added in reverse order

• Sep 28, 2009 - 05:29
Type
Functional
Severity
3
Status
closed
Project
  1. Create a blank document in the key of C
  2. Insert a "D" (2 sharps) key signature in bar 5
  3. Insert a "B♭" (2 flats) key signature in bar 4
  4. Insert another "D" key signature in bar 3

Expected behavior: Key signatures in measures 4 and 5 should display the naturals before it to cancel the previous key

Actual behavior: Key signatures in measure 4 and 5 do not display naturals

Workaround: After step 1 above, do steps 2-4 in reverse

(Tested in r.2133 nightly, Windows XP)

First reported by trombonechamp: http://www.musescore.org/en/node/2881#comment-6919


Comments

Severity
Status (old) fixed active

If the user does an edit->undo after inserting a key signatures (in the above example, the ones found in m4 and m3), the naturals will not update with the edit->undo, but will instead maintain the naturals of the previous key signature.

Severity
Status (old) active fixed

Another attempt to catch all cases: should be fixed now in rev. 2165.