connecting two notes with "Linie" or '+' key causes crash
Reported version
3.5
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
needs info
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
1: loading: greatest_love_of_all_0v2.mscz
2: trying to link two notes like in screen shot: "musescore_issue.png"
3: pressing the '+' key ->crash.
See also: musescore_issue_crash_reporter.png
Revision:
OS: Windows 10 (10.0),
Arch.: x86_64,
MuseScore version (64-bit): 3.5.2.311459983,
revision: 465e7b6
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| greatest_love_of_all_0v2.mscz | 19.3 KB |
| musescore_issue.png | 24.21 KB |
| musescore_issue_crash_reporter.png | 15.3 KB |
Comments
This score has become corrupt - or more particular, the parts have, which is why MuseScore doesn't report the problem. If you delete the parts in File / Parts then regenerate them, all is well.
If you have any insight into how the corruption might have happened, that would help in debugging. But due to the unusual namiung and arrangement of them, I'm kind of guessing you might be seeing the effects of #313664: Reversing the order of the instruments after creating parts leads to very bad result (corruption/crashes).
In the attached mscz-file I've played around with Layers when starting to work on that file. After some trying I removed that to continue without that. Now I've created a new file, copied the piano Instrument via Clipboard from the problematic file to a new file. Now it works much more stable.
Hope this hint helps you identifying the issue.
In reply to In the attached mscz-file I… by karsten.spries…
All the "ties" in your score are actually slurs. Surprising as you mention using "+" to add them, but if you select one and look in the inspector it will tell you that you have selected a slur.
Do you really mean Layers, an experimental feature that is only visible when using the -x copmmand line option?
Probably Voices was meant, Layers is the Finale term for a similar feature. But yes, there are slurs there currently, I was guessing the problem was meant to be if you tried replacing one with a tie. And I can reproduce in that case - because, again, of the corrupt part(s).