Every time I open a specific file Musescore crashes

• Dec 16, 2024 - 11:49

Hello,
I've been working on a file for a number of weeks, and a few days ago every time I would open it, it would crash. I updated Musescore to 4.4.4. to see if it will help, but that didn't work. Yesterday and today I spent 12 hours renotating everything. I even saved files along the way just in case. Finally I finished, but now it does that again, including all the files I saved except for the first one. I'm not sure what I did wrong, and I would very much appreciate it if someone could please explain it to me or fix the file.
Musescore does still open other projects of mine, it just really hates this one.

Attachment	Size
Nadneda.mscz	174.55 KB

Comments

Jojo-Schmitz

• Dec 16, 2024 - 12:06

Confirmed, it crashes in 4.4.4 as well as in latest master. As does 4.3.2 and 4.2.1

My MuseScore 3.7 Evolution opens it without crashing, so maybe the attached Mu3 version of your score help to get along? It does open in 4.4.4 too

Attachment	Size
Nadneda-3.mscz	93.12 KB

Jojo-Schmitz

• Dec 16, 2024 - 12:33

Best report this in GitHub, https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/new/choose

The crash has something to do with accidentals on ornaments (here a flat on a trill), setting an accidental role an a non-existing (?) accidental, whatever that means

Stack trace:
MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::Accidental::setRole(mu::engraving::AccidentalRole r) Line 80 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::Ornament::manageAccidentalVisibilityRules(mu::engraving::Note * note) Line 353 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::Ornament::computeNotesAboveAndBelow(mu::engraving::AccidentalState * accState) Line 317 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::Chord::cmdUpdateNotes(mu::engraving::AccidentalState * as, unsigned __int64 staffIdx) Line 1714 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::rendering::score::ModifyDom::cmdUpdateNotes(const mu::engraving::Measure * measure, const mu::engraving::rendering::score::DomAccessor & dom) Line 124 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::rendering::score::MeasureLayout::layoutMeasure(mu::engraving::MeasureBase * currentMB, mu::engraving::rendering::score::LayoutContext & ctx) Line 885 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::rendering::score::MeasureLayout::getNextMeasure(mu::engraving::rendering::score::LayoutContext & ctx) Line 1060 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::rendering::score::SystemLayout::collectSystem(mu::engraving::rendering::score::LayoutContext & ctx) Line 272 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::rendering::score::PageLayout::collectPage(mu::engraving::rendering::score::LayoutContext & ctx) Line 224 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::rendering::score::ScorePageViewLayout::doLayout(mu::engraving::rendering::score::LayoutContext & ctx) Line 209 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::rendering::score::ScorePageViewLayout::layoutPageView(mu::engraving::Score * score, mu::engraving::rendering::score::LayoutContext & ctx, const mu::engraving::Fraction & stick, const mu::engraving::Fraction & etick) Line 193 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::rendering::score::ScoreLayout::layoutRange(mu::engraving::Score * score, const mu::engraving::Fraction & st, const mu::engraving::Fraction & et) Line 87 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::rendering::score::ScoreRenderer::layoutScore(mu::engraving::Score * score, const mu::engraving::Fraction & st, const mu::engraving::Fraction & et) Line 49 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::Score::doLayoutRange(const mu::engraving::Fraction & st, const mu::engraving::Fraction & et) Line 5848 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::Score::update(bool resetCmdState, bool layoutAllParts) Line 490 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::engraving::Score::update() Line 537 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::project::NotationProject::doLoad(const muse::io::path_t & path, const muse::io::path_t & stylePath, bool forceMode, const std::string & format) Line 201 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::project::NotationProject::load(const muse::io::path_t & path, const muse::io::path_t & stylePath, bool forceMode, const std::string & format_) Line 121 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::project::ProjectActionsController::loadProject(const muse::io::path_t & filePath) Line 292 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::project::ProjectActionsController::doOpenProject(const muse::io::path_t & filePath) Line 327 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::project::ProjectActionsController::openProject(const muse::io::path_t & givenPath, const QString & displayNameOverride) Line 275 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::project::ProjectActionsController::openProject(const mu::project::ProjectFile & file) Line 194 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::project::ProjectActionsController::openProject(const muse::actions::ActionData & args) Line 180 C++ MuseScore4.exe!muse::actions::IActionsDispatcher::reg::__l2::::operator()(const std::string & __formal, const muse::actions::ActionData & data) Line 88 C++ [External Code] MuseScore4.exe!muse::actions::ActionsDispatcher::dispatch(const std::string & actionCode, const muse::actions::ActionData & data) Line 69 C++ MuseScore4.exe!muse::actions::ActionsDispatcher::dispatch(const std::string & actionCode) Line 44 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::project::ScoresPageModel::openOther() Line 46 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::project::ScoresPageModel::qt_static_metacall(QObject * _o, QMetaObject::Call _c, int _id, void * * _a) Line 113 C++ MuseScore4.exe!mu::project::ScoresPageModel::qt_metacall(QMetaObject::Call _c, int _id, void * * _a) Line 196 C++ [External Code] MuseScore4.exe!main(int argc, char * * argv) Line 206 C++ [External Code]

Jojo-Schmitz

• Dec 16, 2024 - 13:37

Culprit part of the score:

            <Trill>
              <subtype>trill</subtype>
              <eid>61306363183201</eid>
              <Ornament>
                <Accidental>
                  <subtype>accidentalFlat</subtype>
                  <eid>1023542246244368</eid>
                  <placement>above</placement>
                  </Accidental>
                <intervalAbove>second,minor</intervalAbove>
                <ornamentShowAccidental>1</ornamentShowAccidental>
                <subtype>ornamentTrill</subtype>
                <eid>61314953117729</eid>
                </Ornament>
              </Trill>

Just removing that <ornamentShowAccidental>1</ornamentShowAccidental> fixes the crash, it is the first of the two trills in the score, both in measure 66, Oboe
And changing its setting for "Visibility of accidentals" causes the crash again