issues with tying a dotted quarter to an eighth note

• Dec 27, 2010 - 21:42
Type
Functional
Severity
S4 - Minor
Status
closed
Project

I am working on a score, and it will not allow me to tie a dotted quarter note to an eighth note. I am using Musescore 0.9.6.3 on Windows XP. When I try to tie a dotted quarter note to the last note in the attached score, the eighth note turns into a dotted quarter note.

Attachment Size
Bebop.mscz 3.43 KB

Comments

I can reproduce, but the problem is another one, I think.

A method that works:
- select last note (Gb)
- enter note entry mode: "n"
- enter a Gb: "g" NUM-minus
- select dotted quarter note: NUM-5 NUM-dot
- add tie: hit NUM-plus
result: Gb eighth with tied dotted quarter note

When you tried the above, please reopen the file, or you can get an "cmdAddTie: has already tie?" from line 870, which is another thing.

What doesn't work, is:
- select rest after last note
- create dotted quarter Gb as above: "n" NUM-5 NUM-dot "g" NUM-minus
- select previous note: CUR-left
- exit note entry mode: ESC
- try to tie the notes: NUM-plus or click the "add tie" symbol

the debugger tells me, that in edit.cpp:905 (Score::cmdAddTie()), where it says
if (n->pitch() == note->pitch()) {
the pitch of the eighth note ("n") is 66 and the one of the dotted quarter note ("note") is 67, so it somehow doesn't interpret the b.

I'll file a new bug report about this issue with a link to this br, meanwhile, the workaround described above should do it.

I can't reproduce this bug. I did the following:

  1. select rest after last note
  2. create dotted quarter Gb as above: "n" NUM-5 NUM-dot "g" NUM-minus
  3. select previous note: CUR-left
  4. exit note entry mode: ESC
  5. try to tie the notes: NUM-plus or click the "add tie" symbol

And I end up with two tied Gb.

Status (old) needs info closed

I can't reproduce this in 1.2 or the nightly. Given the comments, I am not convinced it ever was a bug - most likely just a user misunderstanding.