Note Anchored Line does not appear until save/reload
Reported version
3.0
Priority
P1 - High
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
closed
Regression
Yes
Workaround
Yes
Project
Add two consecutive notes to a score. Select them both. Add / Lines / Note Anchored Line.
Result: line does not appear. But, save & reload, and now it does. Worked in 3.0.4, not sure what's off now. Wild guess: tick() not doing the right thing?
Fix version
3.1.0
Comments
Can't reproduce, works for me.
Shouldn't it rather be "Notes anchored line" as it requires 2 notes?
Also these lines seem to need a ~0.5sp X-offset, to go from notehead center to center rather than left edge plus a bit (line thickness?) to left edge
Actually I can reproduce in current master, but not in 3.0.5
See this:
![note-anchored-line.png]( "note-anchored-line.png")
(zoom in and see it overshooting the left edge if the 1st note)
Becomes even more apparent if the pitch is more different.
Yes, the layout isn't great either, but that's not new, been that way since the beginning (worse in 2.3.2 than 3.0.5 or master)
Well, in MuseScore 2 they didn't even touch the noteheads at all and had to be dragged into place, so this overshooting went unnoticed
I'd rather have them being laid out like straight glissando (of course without text and playback).
Might solve the issue at hand here (glissandos display without the need to save/close/reload) and the layout issue
yet another sub-issue: why isn't it in any palette?
That too could get fixed quite easily by deriving it from a gliss
Not sure. Maybe because it was kind of an afterthought and not fully implemented at first, also there would be confusion as you wouldn't be tell it apart from a regular line (unless we used an icon, that showed it with notes at either end).
In reply to Not sure. Maybe because it… by Marc Sabatella
yes, like 90° ambitus. Or maybe better ~60° (and with a longer line maybe)
https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/4956
Fixed in branch master, commit 17c3bfaeeb
fix #285602: note line does not appear until reload
Fixed in branch master, commit 613c26ce9b
_Merge pull request #4956 from MarcSabatella/285602-noteline
fix #285602: note line does not appear until reload_
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.