Range select -> "Notes" button in Inspector includes grace notes in list selection, disabling Inspector

• Nov 1, 2015 - 14:47
Reported version
2.1
Type
Functional
Severity
S4 - Minor
Status
closed
Project

See https://musescore.org/en/node/85151. Grace notes are not the same as other notes, and if two different types of elements are selected the Inspector can't be used.


Comments

How do you think it should be fixed?
Should there be another option to select "grace notes" next to "notes" in inspector?
And then pressing "notes" only selects non-"grace notes"?

First priority is to make sure that the "Notes" button does not include grace notes. But adding another button in the middle to select grace notes seems like a fine idea, too.

I tested it, it work nicely but it kills the ability to select all the notes *including* grace notes from a selection. Currently we can select all notes including gracenotes with the inspector and we can select only notes or only grace notes with right click > select similar element in selection.

Do we really want this?

The whole point is to remove the ability to select all notes including grace notes, because there's nothing you can do if both are selected—the Inspector gets into a situation where it can tell there is a mixed selection, so it offers you a button to select only the notes in the selection; clicking that button selects both notes and grace notes in a mixed selection, so the Inspector offers you a button to select only the notes in the selection; and so on.

We do really want this.

Status (old) active fixed

Fixed in branch 2.1, commit fe10e1bbf0

fix #85631: Range select -> Notes button in Inspector includes grace...

...notes in list selection, disabling Inspector

Backport of 3b3d74b to the 2.1 branch