Different Voices, *Different Dynamics*
UwU -I mean... What happens if I want THIS:
And similar stuff... Both voices in the above example, are played FF. I wanted the second voice to sound P but failed. I think Musescore should implement dynamics which will apply the corresponding volume only to the voice it belongs.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| NIEEEK!.png | 20.98 KB |
Comments
See #58031: Dynamics/hairpin range for Voice
In reply to See #58031: Dynamics/hairpin… by Jojo-Schmitz
Should have known better. Thanks.
In reply to Should have known better… by [DELETED] 32872726
It seems as though MuseScore doesn't assign dynamics to any voice at all. But rather to the staff as a whole. I think that this is true of any notation software.
In reply to It seems as though MuseScore… by bobjp
This may change in version 4 though I've heard nothing definitive.
In reply to It seems as though MuseScore… by bobjp
For the record, the dynamic is assigned to a specific voice, which you can see if you select it and check the color. However, for playback purposes, it currently assumes any dynamic in any voice applies to them all. I doubt it would be particularly hard to enhance that.
+ 1
I am working with a score which requires exactly what the OP's picture shows so it's a thumbs up from me for voice level dynamic control.
I'm not sure about the hairpin workaround since I have experience of using other workarounds that don't always make sense to other systems when using MusicXML as an interface so I would sooner wait for the functionality to be added rather than 'twist' an existing function to fit my use. I will therefore use voice selection and velocity from inspector.