Musescore stop working when notate pitch which lower than A0
I recently transcribing more Bartok and I need to go down to Ab0 (extra lower note on Imperiel Bosendorfer?)
But I always got noti stopped working which is bad. The new update doesn't allow to do this?
Comments
Could you attach here your score?
In reply to Could you attach here your… by Shoichi
Yes. but I know already how to. It was my mistake that I didn't use 8va bassa Lol. Sorry. :P. Now it's okay already. I should have check everything before questioning.
In reply to Yes. but I know already how… by Foxiszt
But reporting the solution found can help others.
Buona musica!
In reply to But reporting the solution… by Shoichi
Oh darn.... now it's really bad for me. I crashed it once and I didn't save my work.
I lost two page...
I was gone really mad. Like. I wanna kill myself. put a sigh emoji here
Tbh, This MUST NEED TO FIX!
In reply to Oh darn.... now it's really… by Foxiszt
"I crashed it once"
By doing what exactly (provide please precise steps) with your attached score? : Bartok_0.mscz
In reply to *"I crashed it once *"… by cadiz1
It happen with another score that I also working on. When I went down more than A0. it crash (or stopped working), and it didn't save any my progress... So I have to do it again.
Hope you understand. because I don't really understand your question. I'm little bad at English. :/
In reply to It happen with another score… by Foxiszt
"It happen with another score that I also working on"
So, please attach this specific score and by providing steps which leads to "stop working"
In reply to "It happen with another… by cadiz1
Let's replace 'another' with 'every'.
It happen to 'every' piece. I tried to make new files and goes lower; it happen the same.
I guess it's bug.
But here. Take this anyway...
In reply to Let's replace 'another' with… by Foxiszt
What happens and how to reproduce, exact description and steps please.
Just taking the 1st note in bass clef and moving that down (to C-1, the lowest possible pitch in MuseScore and MIDI) using cursor keys doesn't crash nor hang.
Did you by chance double click a note and then move it down with cursor keys? That puts the note into edit mode and only moves the note visually, without change the pitch, press Esc to get out of that mode
In reply to What happens and how to… by Jojo-Schmitz
Nah.... I didn't double clicked it to edit mode.
It hard to explain steps. I still don't understand what exactly 'steps' di you mean. It's only just crash when I notated a pitch lower than A0.
Sorry. That's the thing that I can only tell. :(
In reply to Nah.... I didn't double… by Foxiszt
How are you entering that note below A0?
In reply to How are you entering that A0? by Jojo-Schmitz
Piano score in C-Major, select a rest in bass clef, press N, A, ↓, Ctrl+↓, Ctrl+↓ and voila: an Ab0, another Ctrl+↓ and you even get an Ab-1
So these are steps to not reproduce the problem, but the right way to enter such a note. So again the question: how are you entering that Ab0?
In reply to Piano score, select a rest… by Jojo-Schmitz
First attachment: That's A0. And if I press an arrow down; the program is crash as the second attachment (stwk)
Second attachment is also the result that you lead me to do it.
In reply to First attachment: That's A0… by Foxiszt
Doesn't crash here at all.
Appart from that this is a A2, not an A0, check the status bar
In reply to Doesn't crash here at all. by Jojo-Schmitz
Jojo-Schmitz: Oh... I think it happen only me? :(
cadiz01: Thank you! Hope it get fixed. This bug is really annoying!
In reply to Piano score, select a rest… by Jojo-Schmitz
First attachment: That's A0. And if I press an arrow down; the program is crash as the second attachment (stwk)
Second attachment is also the result that you lead me to do it.
In reply to Piano score, select a rest… by Jojo-Schmitz
Okay, I get it: on any score -> Press "P" (virtual keyboard) -> select a measure > "N" -> click on the first key (A0) -> arrow down -> crash
In reply to Okay, I get it. Reported… by cadiz1
Ah! Indeed. So going below A0 crashes MuseScore when the virtual piano keybord is open.
In reply to Ah! Indeed. by Jojo-Schmitz
Please Jojo, fill the problem in the Issue Tracker.
A bit in hurry here right now. Thanks.
In reply to Please Jojo, fill the issue… by cadiz1
Done, see #271677: Crash when the virtual piano keybord is open and a note outside its range gets selected or entered
Edit: darn, created a duplicate, see #271325: Adjusting a note outside the range of a piano causes a crash when the piano keyboard is visible., fixed in 2.3
In reply to Oh darn.... now it's really… by Foxiszt
Glad the crash is identified now. But FWIW, you shouldn't ever lose (much) work after a crash. MuseScore automatically auto-saves every two minutes. After a crash, MuseScore should offer to recover your last sessions. Simply answer yes and you should find most of your intact. Best to then do a "save as" just in case.