Applying beam properties to rests produces strange beams/stems in neighbouring notes

• Aug 13, 2011 - 05:39
Type
Functional
Severity
S4 - Minor
Status
closed
Project

If there is no note to connect to, applying beam properties to a note or rest shouldn't be applicable.

1. Create score.
2. Enable 'Note Entry'.
3. Enter semiquaver rest.
4. Enter semiquaver next to the rest.
5. Disable 'Note Entry'.
6. Select rest.
7. Double-click 'Beam start' (from Beam Properties).

Result:

In 1.1, the semiquaver note has a flag of a crotchet.
In the trunk, there is half of a beamed semiquaver.

Using MuseScore 1.1 and 2.0 Nightly Build (4674) - Mac 10.6.8.


Comments

Title Single notes/rests with no proper connection should not affected by beam properties Beam properties of notes with no legit connection to another are changeable
Title Beam properties of notes with no legit connection to another are changeable Applying beam properties to notes with no connection to another produces strange results
Title Applying beam properties to notes with no connection to another produces strange results Applying beam properties to rests produces strange beams/stems in neighbouring notes

Think it's just rests.

Not sure of the rules on why it's happening (was able to do the treble clef in this score, so doesn't happen in every instance), but I can provide another example:

1. Open attached score.
2. Click the first semiquaver rest in the bass clef.
3. In 'Beam Properties', double-click 'Middle of beam'.

Using MuseScore 1.1 and 2.0 Nightly Build (4683) - Mac 10.6.8.

I think the behaviour is correct and intended. The "middle beam" property means that the note/rest should be beamed. The naming of the property is probably misleading. It does not necessarily beam the neighbour rests/notes.
Beams starting with a rest are also common. Sometimes a short stem is attached from beam to rest (which is not supported in MuseScore).

Following the same steps in current build (b424d8ef47) results in the stem for the note extending all the way off the page. The beam is correct - it shows the partial beam as it should - just the stem is messed up.