Section Break duration wrongly extends pedal sustain on piano
I came across this feature, where a closing chord with pedal sustain in the piano part should terminate after three beats. But in playback the sustain is extended in addition for the entire duration of the Section Break (in this example the section break is exaggerated to 5 seconds).
Anyone care to confirm that this is a fault?
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Section Break wrongly extends pedal sustain.mscz | 21.09 KB |
Comments
(edited: deleted, without having seen the following comment)
In reply to Right-click on the section… by cadiz1
@cadiz1 [edit: wrongly responded to someone else] You're right, but surely that's a workaround rather than a comment as to whether this is a fault or not? I had deliberately changed the section break duration to 5 seconds, just to demonstrate the effect when posting the example score...
My feeling is that a Section Break duration should be silent, like the gap between tracks on a CD. What do you think?
In reply to @jeetee You're right, but… by DanielR
Sorry, I have not studied the question enough, and it's late now here :)
I leave it to others to comment.
I'd call or a bug, and not the only for section breaks
I can confirm, including in a new score created from scratch. If the pedal extends all the way to the end of the measure, playback continues into the break. That's a bug. Feel free to report it formally to the issue tracker; I don't see any similar report there already.
In reply to I can confirm, including in… by Marc Sabatella
Raised in issue tracker: https://musescore.org/en/node/275983