Images attached to rests not imported from MuseScore 2
Reported version
3.0
Priority
P1 - High
Type
Functional
Frequency
Few
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Randomly
Status
closed
Regression
Yes
Workaround
No
Project
Images added to a score in v2 (like swing_marking_8ths.svg or swing_marking_16ths.svg) are not showing up when opening the score in v3alpha.
(MuseScore-2018-10-31-1202-3.0alpha2-3abd82b.dmg)
Fix version
3.4.0
Comments
Works for me, in latest development builds at least. Please try with that and if you can still reproduce attach a sample score showing the issue
My version is listed in the 1st post. 'Help' - 'Check for Updates' says: 'you're up-to-date'.
I tried with and without resetting positions on load in v3alpha without success.
Please try with the latest development version, you get it from https://musescore.org/en/download#Development-builds
Anyway, with that score I can reproduce, not with one of mine though
In reply to Please try with the latest… by Jojo-Schmitz
Same in MuseScoreNightly-2018-11-13-1009-master-d410c50.dmg.
I tend to disagree with 'randomly'. It happens with all my scores with the swing marking images. But I understand why you changed it.
As drag&drop from Finder and my loaded palette don't work (filed cases about them), I tried re-adding by copy paste from a score opened in v2. After save and quit&restart (or reload) in v3alpha, the image is still there. Must be something on import.
because a) it looked like our posts crossed (you also changed Regression and Status) and b) doesn't happen for my scores, so doesn't reproduce reliably
and did it again. It is a regression (vs. 2.x) and currently, with your sample score, don't need more infos.
Sorry, but I've just entered text and hit 'Save'. No idea how I changed it without touching it. (No joke!) I've just restarted my browser now...
Thanks for listening and helping!
no problem, this happens when 2 persons are writing at the same time
I've got two more observations about images in v3alpha2:
1) Copy in v2, paste in v3alpha2 works for one swing marking image but not for the other.
2) I cannot move the pasted swing marking image with mouse/trackpad in v3alpha2 the way I can in v2.
Shall I create new, separate cases?
I can confirm 2) need to select it and move via inspector, which is quite annoying indeed (but a workaround)
Can you attach or point to the SVG that doesn't work?
The ones from https://musescore.org/en/node/266325? I can paste them both
OK, I'll drop 2), because it's already known.
For 1) I'm using swing_marking_8ths.svg and swing_marking_16ths.svg from https://musescore.org/en/node/266325. I already made a screen recording, but I cannot attach anything to this thread anymore. It ignores 'Choose a file' and drag&drop.
Maybe it's because I'm pulling them from my palette in v2 and then copy them over to v3alpha2?
I don't want to hijack this thread for a different issue. I think I better create a new one?
2) is not known, not in the sense of having an issue of its own entry here in the tracker, so yes, create one
I can attach here, no problem
I now got a warning that I cannot upload movies.
New one coming.
yes, some formats (or rather their extensions) are not allowed here. SVG is though, ZIP is too ;-)
And for videos you could use animated gifs
see: #278383: images can't be moved with mouse
My understanding of the bottom line here: at least for this particular, the image is not being imported. Not sure if we understand any more than that? Still, that seems serious enough to warrant "critical" priority - people actually use images for lots of things.
The problem is that images could not be copied from version 2 to version 3, not like "images don't work in version 3".
Right, import from MuseScore 2 only. A quick test suggests that images in frames come through fine, as do images images attached to notes. Images attached to rests seem to be the ones lost.
came up again in #287205: Missing pictures, along with another sample score
See https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/5550
Fixed in branch master, commit 0d1262d25c
_fix #278169: images attached to rests not imported from MuseScore 2
Resolves: https://musescore.org/en/node/278169
The code to read an Image tag attached to a note was present in read206.cpp
but the analogous code for a rest was missing. The same has been added._
Fixed in branch master, commit 48235c4d55
_Merge pull request #5550 from Kartikay26/278169-image-attached-to-rest
fix #278169: images attached to rests not imported from MuseScore 2_
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.