improve musicXML import (from sibelius export)

• Nov 15, 2018 - 19:16
Reported version
2.3
Type
Functional
Frequency
Many
Severity
S4 - Minor
Reproducibility
Always
Status
active
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
Tags

Hi all!
I try to import score that was crated from sibelius as musicXML.

I discover that have several format issues:
- chord names aligment are incorrect
- invalid characters on chords names, example: F# -> F(c) on measure 17
- lost chords (ej measure 21, original have A and Asemi, imported have only A+-
- free text with lyrics (end of pages) lost line breaks and formating.

i attach example files:
1) sibelius original file
2) sibelius export as pdf
3) sibelius export as xml
4) musescore imported mscz
5) musescore exported ad pdf

thanks!


Comments

Severity S3 - Major S4 - Minor

Thanks for the detailed report. Unfortunately, with the possible exception of incorrect chord names alignment, all issues are caused by the Sibelius export.

invalid characters on chords names, example: F# -> F(c) on measure 17: chords have been exported as plain text and are displayed by MuseScore exactly as exported by Sibelius

lost chords (ej measure 21, original have A and Asemi, imported have only A+-: all chords present in the MusicXML file are displayed by MuseScore exactly as exported by Sibelius

free text with lyrics (end of pages) lost line breaks and formatting: Sibelius did not export any formatting

With respect to chord names alignment, this would require further investigation, which I cannot do right now. I do not consider alignment a high priority issue. Note that the chord names alignment can easily be fixed using the inspector.