Start repeat causes hairpin to extend to end of next measure
Reported version
3.1
Priority
P1 - High
Type
Graphical (UI)
Frequency
Once
Severity
S2 - Critical
Reproducibility
Always
Status
duplicate
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
When I put a hairpin in a measure with "start refrain" bar line, the hairpin gets longer than the measure that it's referred.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Ex._hairpin_bug.mscz | 5.44 KB |
Comments
Confirmed
I clarified up the name and raised the severity. I chose Critical because there is no way I found to fix this and it's a common notation. Frequency changed to 1 since this is the first report to my knowledge.
The hair pin needs to end at the end of the measure before the start repeat. I tried it with a 16th note and many longer notes. The tie doesn't affect the results, only where the note that ends the hairpin matters.
For the record, in 3.0.5 this hairpin becomes shorter rather than longer. It looks like something in 3.1 version changed the old wrong behavior to the new one.
There was a bug during 3.1-beta that if their was a start repeat after a line, the line would shorten. It was fixed and I believe it probably caused this bug. I can't find the bug report though.
See #288508: Bad layout of lines (text line, trill line...) before start repeat. I imagine it's the same issue.
The one I'm thinking of I thought was fixed. I think by you, Marc, but you've fixed so many bugs I don't know for sure.
Thanks, but this one was fixed by Matt :-). If you follow the thread, it was fixed, or at the PR for it was merged, but somehow it didn't work. maybe something else changed that invalidated the fix. Not sure.
The original PR for #288508: Bad layout of lines (text line, trill line...) before start repeat had a flaw, and there is a new PR to correct it which fixes this issue. I am marking this as a duplicate because this is in fact the same issue.