Lines other than ottavas should not start at accidental
Ubuntu 14.04, GIT commit: 9e4f002
See https://musescore.org/en/node/67081#comment-307111 for original report.
A while back I made a change so that ottavas would align with accidentals rather than the notehead, as per Gould. But my change inadvertently also applied to trills, hairpins, and textlines.
It's a sinple change, and definitely the right thing for trills and hairpins at least. Textlines are generic enough that I suppose some people might want it one way, others another. I'll do a little quick research to see if it makes sense to special case them too, but I'm inclined to have ottavas be the only ones that align with accidentals.
Comments
https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/2115
I think it makes more sense to treat text lines like most other lines rather than include them in the special casing for ottavas, so that's what I have gone ahead and done.
Agree with that.
![BII.jpg]( "BII.jpg")
See the following image from a published score.
Fixed in branch master, commit b7c9e15953
fix #68331: line other than ottava should not start at accidental
Fixed in branch master, commit ab0ba20681
Merge pull request #2115 from MarcSabatella/hairpin-accidental
fix #68331: line other than ottava should not start at accidental
Fixed in branch 2.0.2, commit 81a8292050
fix #68331: line other than ottava should not start at accidental
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.