Zerberus exports silence instead of audio
Please see this forum discussion for details...
https://musescore.org/en/node/101151
I can confirm this behaviour, and I have uploaded the relevant files to this Google Drive Folder......
https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B7cZM0RQwkwSMl91UXJfeEM5Wnc
Files are...
1. PosGedact8SFZ.zip - the SFZ font loaded into Zerberus to do the test.
2. AudioExportTestSFZ.flac - audio export from MuseScore in FLAC format
3. AudioExportTestSFZ.wav - audio export from MuseScore in WAV format
4. AudioExportSFZ.mscz - the source score exported as audio.
If you need anything else post here!
My System: Windows 10 Pro version 1511 build 10586.122, MuseScore 2.0.2 rev f51dc11
Comments
I'm looking into it as my first bug.
I /think/ there is something fishy going on at zerberus.cpp:177.
[ please disregard ]
Did you remember to use the "Save to Score" button before exporting?
Whoops. I have apparently been chasing my own tail.
It seems to work fine with the latest master under Ubuntu LTS, Qt 5.5, in fact.
I can even export ChurchOrganist's mscz.
Perhaps it's a Windows-only problem?
I encountered it on OS X. Perhaps it's something that's been fixed since 2.0.2?
Don't be silly Zack!
There's no such thing as a silly question, ChurchOrganist :-)
Just tried in 2.0.3 r02f543d
It works fine, although for some reason the right channel exported louder than the left.
So this must have been fixed at some point after 2.02 was released.
So I guess we can regard this as fixed guys :)
Perhaps one of you running Mac OSX could try with a nightly build just to be sure??
Just FYI, "Did you remember to use the "Save to Score" button before exporting?" was in response to a post from tobiatesan reporting that not only were SFZ sounds not being exported, but neither were any non-default SF2s. It was not a response to your original bug report.
Ah! I misunderstood - maybe he should have let his post stand instead of removing it - that would have then been clear :)
Sorry, I was hoping not to add too much noise for something that was basically me not understanding how the thing is supposed to work.
Apparently, I got the opposite effect. Sorry about that.
Apparently this was reported and fixed some time ago - see #34286: zerberus exports silence. So I'm closing this. Reopen if you can provide steps to reproduce in a current build.
Well, that fix was in 2.0.2 already, so it can't be a duplicate of a problem reported against 2.0.2
This obviously isn't a duplicate as it is a report of a problem in 2.0.2, as Jojo has just said.
It does seem to be fixed in 2.0.3 nightly builds, but please will someone check it works on OSX and then mark as fixed or not depending on the result.
I verified that it works correctly on OS X in the latest 2.0.3 nightly build. Thanks!
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.