Wrong (?) clef for 1.3 score with odd (invalid?) clef change

• May 10, 2014 - 18:31
Type
Functional
Severity
3
Status
closed
Project
MuseScore

Windows 7, GIT commit: 7dbe499

Have I made it clear enough from the title I'm not sure how much of a bug this is?

1) open attached score (found on musescore.com) in 1.3 and a 2.0 build
2) look at measures 5-6, top staff

Result: in 1.3, these are in bass clef, but in 2.0, they are in treble clef.

The notes display properly for the clef displayed - this isn't one of those bugs where notes display incorrectly for the displayed clef. It's just that the clef is "wrong". I put that in quotes because if you look more closely at the score in 1.3, you see a bass clef at the beginning of the system, but a courtesy treble clef at the end of the previous system. I think I'd rather have what I see in 2.0, because then the problem is more apparent and I can fix it. But I figured this was worth logging.

Comments

• May 12, 2014 - 16:59

The MSCX contains a completely empty Clef markup. But it's not listed in the clef list. A possible fix could be to ignore clefs that are not in the cleflist, for 1.3 scores. I will commit such a fix, hope it doesn't break anything :)

Reply