Vertical position of two Volta brackets should be the same
Reported version
3.0
Priority
P0 - Critical
Type
Functional
Frequency
Few
Severity
S2 - Critical
Reproducibility
Always
Status
closed
Regression
No
Workaround
Yes
Project
If there are elements below a volta which do move it up, then successive voltas have different vertical positions.
Expected: Successive voltas should have the same vertical position.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| volta-skyline.mscz | 2.76 KB |
Comments
I can confirm this.
Expected: Successive voltas should have the same vertical position if on the same system.
I can have also seen this, but I didn't report it immediately, because in my case, the second volta would've collided with notes in the staff on top if it was moved to the same level. I did try to cram in a lot of music on the page, so I decreased the min system distance quite a bit. So my case was a bit more complex for the autoplacement engine.
Lyrics are pushed down as a whole (in the whole line of that staff in that system) if one note in the system needs it. Voltas should do the same (just up rather than down of course)
Maybe not all voltas in the same system, but all neighbouring voltas (in the system)
Jojo, agreed ;-) I think you summarised the expected behaviour very well. All voltas directly adjacent to each other should be aligned.
This seems to be working well now, isn't it?
In reply to This seems to be working… by dmitrio95
Yes, that seems to be fixed.
Now all voltas in the same system get the same height.
But I agree with Jojo, only adjacent voltas in the same staff should be aligned.
So, fixed? And separate issues if any.
#278480: Only adjacent volta brackets should have the same height
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.