'Straight' text does not work, since all options in the "Swing settings" tab are unchecked

• Feb 13, 2020 - 23:29
Reported version
3.4
Type
Functional
Frequency
Few
Severity
S4 - Minor
Reproducibility
Always
Status
PR created
Regression
No
Workaround
Yes
Project

To reproduce this issue:
1) Place the Swing text at the beginning of a piece.
2) Place the Straight text anywhere after.
3) Place repeating eighth notes in both sections
After the Swing text is placed, the rest of the piece will be swung, even if there is the Straight text.
Attached is a MuseScore file to show this problem.

Attachment Size
show.mscz 8.35 KB

Comments

Workaround No Yes

The Straight system text is configured to deactivate Swing, unfortunately, deactivate does not change the actual configuration.
To be sure to pass in Straight mode :

Swing_Settings_EN.png

Check the box "Swing Settings"
And in "Swing:" check "Off"
This will pass in Straight mode.

Title 'Straight' text does not make the eighth notes play straight 'Straight' text does not work, since all options in the "Swing settings" tab are unchecked

IMV, the "Swing Settings" check-box could be removed, since the swing status should be apparent from the other display options.

Status active needs info

Maybe I'm missing something, but this is working exactly as designed as far as I can tell. It's crucial that the default settings in this dialog do nothing. not to enable swing, not to disable it, but to do nothing. otherwise, every text element you added would have the side effect of disabling swing So there needs to be a way to distinguish the "do nothing" default from "turn off swing". And that is exactly what the checkbox does.

So, for most text you add, the checkbox is off, meaning, no effect on swing. But if you want an element to specific change the playback to straight, you need to be sure the checkbox is enabled so there is an effect on swing, but the radio button is set to off, so that is the effect.

Just to clarify, we are talking specifically about "Straight" text applied from the "Text" palette of the Advanced workspace (you may need to click on "More" to see it). It should be set up, by default, to countermand a previous swing indication but it is not working.

Severity S3 - Major S4 - Minor
Status needs info active

Ah, I wasn't aware such text existed. Now I see it, and indeed, it's not set up properly.