LH guitar fingering: problem with horizontal position
2.0.3 / Win 10/7.
See Fingerings and accidentals . This fix offsets the LH guitar fingering to avoid accidentals.
However, this "pre-offset" can cause a problem, especially when applying multiple fingerings. One example is where the user has added an extra vertical offset to the style, as in the attached score. The added fingering is now placed well above the note accidental, but the offset fix is still being applied, even though not necessary. Compare the position of the "3" on the two notes below:
Suggestion: Adjust the code, so that if the user changes the vertical offset in the style dialog, it ignores any pre-applied horizontal offset.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| fingering_position_wrong_with_accidental.mscz | 8.67 KB |
Comments
This is perhaps similar to what lasconic said on https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/2318 : "I believe the whole fingering layouting is not good. Using useroffset, we cannot react when the note change. So fingering after transpose will be completely wrong... But ok, this PR doesn't make it worse."
I'm not totally understanding the intended behavior here, but feel free to revisit once https://musescore.org/en/node/267499 is merged.
I am still not sure what the intended result was, but am inclined to think the style setting simply doesn't make sense anymore.
This doesn't seem to be an issue anymore in 3.0, so, IMV, can be closed.
so let's do it...