Faulty Key Signature when transposing without Ctrl +A
Nigthly, August 7 (16c2771) / Windows 7
1) Open « Promenade »
2) Press Ctrl +A
3) -> Notes → Transpose -> Change the key ("closest", Bb major/G minor) to C major/A minor.
Result : Correct
- Now, if you forget to press initially on Ctlr + A, and you go immediatly to Notes -> Transpose: you see displayed this following message:
4) Select Yes! -> Change and choose the same key -> C major/A minor
Result: the initial key is always displayed
- There are probably others manifestations (I have no made the detail) of this bug.
I seen the following for example:
A chord in C major -> choose D key signature (always without use Ctlr + A)
Result: chord ok, but the D key signature is not displayed.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| 1Promenade CtrlA.jpg | 15.12 KB |
| 2Promenade Ctrl A .jpg | 15.17 KB |
| 3 Nothing selected.jpg | 27.32 KB |
| 4 Promenade fail key .jpg | 16.6 KB |
| 5C major.jpg | 5.59 KB |
| 6 D key non displayed.jpg | 6.28 KB |
Comments
Changing of title, more precise, and another example.
1) New score for flute with a scale in A major
![Scale A flute.jpg]( "Scale A flute.jpg")
2) Notes → Transpose → "Yes" when you see the message to select and transpose the whole score → Change the key (closest) and choose the C key signature.
- Expected result :
![scale flute expected result.jpg]( "scale flute expected result.jpg")
- Actual result :
Confirmed, there is a problem with auto-selecting. I can be wrong but I am almost sure this process excludes key signatures. See mscore/musescore: void MuseScore::transpose() selection start conditions.
Fixed in 4224cfcbbb
Thanks so much folbo. Well done :)
Thanks, I'm still excited :)
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.