"Reset position of all elements" when importing 2.x scores is missing in new "Try our improved style settings" dialog

• Nov 17, 2020 - 06:54
Reported version
3.x-dev
Type
Functional
Frequency
Few
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
closed
Regression
Yes
Workaround
No
Project

OS: Windows 7 SP 1 (6.1), Arch.: x86_64, MuseScore version (64-bit): 3.6.0, revision: fc50932

When importing 2.x score in v3.5.2 (or earlier), the 'Reset Positions Dialog' is displayed :

ResetPosDialog.png

In the last Dev Build, this dialog has been replaced by the 'Improved Style Dialog' :

ImprovedStyleDialog.png

But nothing ask the user if he want to 'reset positions of all elements'

Therefore in Preferences -> Import the choice to ask or not to reset elements is still present :

PrefsResetPos.png

Expected behavior:
- In case of importing a 2.x score, the message, choice, and fonctionality of the previous 'Reset all positions' dialog should be integrated in the new 'Improved style' dialog.


Comments

Title Reset positions of all elements dialog when importing 2.x scores is no more displayed "Reset position of all elements?" dialog (2.x scores): "NO" button is missing
Severity S3 - Major S2 - Critical

IMV, the new dialog is misleading as it gives the impression that resetting is a magic bullet. To take one example: if you are importing a 2.x guitar score with many custom fingerings and lines, the last thing you want is a full reset.

Suggestion: Make the wording of the dialog more neutral and to the point.

Title "Reset position of all elements?" dialog (2.x scores): "NO" button is missing "Reset position of all elements?" dialog (2.x scores): "YES" option is missing
Title "Reset position of all elements?" dialog (2.x scores): "YES" option is missing "Reset position of all elements" dialog missing, when importing 2.x scores

Oops.

Title "Reset position of all elements" dialog missing, when importing 2.x scores "Reset position of all elements" missing in new score import dialog
Title "Reset position of all elements" missing in new score import dialog "Reset position of all elements" when importing 2.x scores is missing in new "Try our improved style settings" dialog
Status active fixed

Please open a new issue for that, as it is unrelated to this here (well, not entirely unrelated)
But I can confirm that other settings are getting changed too, like for 3.5 scores, even when denying the new settings

Fix version
3.6.0