Augm. dot misplaced for low stemless notes
OS: Linux Mint 17.3. Since at least ver. 2.2.1, the augmentation dot for stemless notes below the middle staff line is misplaced. Example from latest PPA version (2.2.1+dfsg1-5~ppa1804+1; 2.3 AppImage result is identical):
As it can be seen in the bass line, the augmentation dot is misplaced to the left the more the lower the note. The current result is practically unreadable and the current version unusable (whence the "critical" status). The same happens with semibreves.
For comparison, the same score as engraved by 2.1 AppImage (which I luckily happen to still have installed):
Comments
So a regression in 2.2, right? No corruption nor loss of information, so a normal priority...
Does the same thing happen in 2.3 or in development builds from the master branch?
Having a sample score here would make it easy to check...
OK, same issue in 2.3, sample score attached
Workaround: select the note, then in Inspector click on Dot 1 (at the bottom), then increase horizontal offset to 1sp
Hmm, major should be OK
And master is affected too
I can't reproduce this with 2.2.1 though, only with 2.3 (and master)
In reply to I can't reproduce this with… by Jojo-Schmitz
Here a sample score: dot.mscz
The dot position re-becomes correct from higher notes (here B4). I check.
Yes,, only notes below the middle staff line are affected, which is the place where notes with stems would flip that into the other direction.
Adding notes in voice 2 also results in the dots to show again (as these would also cause stems to flip). That note in voice 2 can't be made invisible though, then the dots disappear again...
This nightly works (May 10): 7345a8c
Not this one (May 12): 6257956
Maybe a side effect of? https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/commit/c2158578cff4d2923f0dcd1a2…
To fix: #271529: Incorrect stem position for wide noteheads
And because, in Master, commit merged on May 5, this nigthly fails: 727afe5
And as expected in the last nightly the day before: c48048a
Scores on musescore.com are affected too, if uploaded or update after the update to 2.3, i.e. after June 29th
Jojo, thank you for the thoroughly made research. The info about stem flipping position will help a lot.
See https://musescore.org/en/node/273930.
del
Fixed in branch 2.3.1, commit 59483fb69d
fix #273921: incorrect augmentation dot position
Fix dot position and aligned it with noteHeadWidth as it was before, not stemPosX as it has been done (incorrectly?) during refactoring.
Fixed in branch master, commit bebc557ebf
fix #273921: incorrect augmentation dot position
Cherry-pick fix from 2.3.1. Fix dot position and aligned it with noteHeadWidth as it was before, not stemPosX as it has been done (incorrectly?) during refactoring.
BTW, any chance this relates somehow to the user who couldn't see the dots in his tempo palette?
I don't think so, they are neither stemless nor low. It is rather a high res / DPI issue.
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.