Single-note dynamics/crescendos doesn't work with tremolos.
I don't really know if this is a bug or a feature request. When you (that is, the developers) said you were incorporating single-note dynamics and crescendos, I thought that would work for tremolos as well. But it doesn't. Is it a bug or have you just not gotten around to it yet? It's not a critical problem, but it just seems strange to me that this feature was left out. If you want to test it on your own computers, you can use the attached score; I could be missing something. :)
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Tremolo_test.mscz | 5.46 KB |
Comments
Related to #289835: Customized note velocity does not affect single-note dynamics?
Or https://musescore.org/en/node/289883 and https://musescore.org/en/node/289785
Hmm, probably neither, pianos don't do single note dynamics, as that instrument can't do this.
Although on a tremolo they can...
I don't often write for piano, so I've missed this to this point. It seems on the piano the crescendo is ignored in error when you put a tremolo on it. MuseScore thinks that since a piano cannot crescendo a single note it should ignore all whole notes with a hairpin under it. We all know that this is in reality a series of notes, so the crescendo should be heard. This explains some rolls with hairpins that weren't sounding right to me on a marimba.
In reply to I don't often write for… by mike320
That makes sense. I don't have any experience coding MuseScore, but is there a way to make an exception in the programming for tremolos? Something like, if tremolo = true, then enable single-note dynamics for that instrument for that specific section of the score. (If that's even possible)
In reply to That makes sense. I don't… by WilsonE7
Esp. as it isn't really single notes, but a rapid succession of several notes, each of which could play with a different (de- or increasing) velocity
In reply to Esp. as it isn't really… by Jojo-Schmitz
Okay, maybe there's a way to get musescore to treat single notes with tremolos as a series of notes. That way, hairpins would work just like normal.
In reply to Okay, maybe there's a way to… by WilsonE7
Might be worth getting into the issue tracker
Edit: thanks for #289898: Cresc./dim. are ignored for tremolos.
Thanks, this is something that has been an issue before single-note dynamics. I'll look into getting it fixed for you :)
In reply to Thanks, this is something… by TheOtherJThistle
Thank you. I'm sure many of us are looking forward to it.