detached stem after fix notes to line
Reported version
3.0
Priority
P1 - High
Type
Functional
Severity
S3 - Major
Status
closed
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
on github-musescore-musescore-d61b0d open attached file of this measure:
1. select all notes in attached score via inspector
2. press Fix to line 0.
result has the stems detached from the noteheads:
It seems after doing some operations (I don't know what exactly), the glitch will fix itself.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| detached_stem_when_fix_to_line_0.mscz | 3.45 KB |
Comments
Even if already fixed to a line, this glitch still happens when changing the line number.
the fact that it fixes itself after further edits suggests the problem is that we are not properly relaying out the measure, presumably a result of the new partial relayout code and the flags not being set correctly. Or something like that. I keep putting off spending the necessary time to get inside and understand the new layout code, but since the fix to line code was mine to begin with, I guess I'll take this as an opportunity.
Confirmed.
One way to fix stems is to select the notehead of the broken note and press Up or Down.
Not sure why that is major? It is just a visual glitch, I'd rather see it minor
IMHO, since it is about 3.0alpha-06 which means sharing the current state of 3.0 more or less publicly, I think about the number of feedback from users. Such visual glitches lead to the most number of requests, I believe. So, it is not major for functionality, but is major in terms of user experience.
Confirmed for 5ad448c
Also I attached the file converted to the new MuseScore 3 fileformat.
The reason is in not called relayouting for stems somewhere. Workaround: select stems, Check "Automatic placement" off (fixes the positions) and then on.
Fixed in branch master, commit b64b60a7b4
fix #146991 detached stem after fix notes to line
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.