Stemless in Inspector not processing beamed notes correctly
1. Open attached score (produced in 1.3).
2. 'Inspector'.
3. Click on the fourth grace note of the first normal note.
Result: 'Stemless' isn't ticked.
4. Tick it.
Result: Stem re-appears.
5. Untick it.
Result: Stem doesn't disappear.
Discussion: If you perform steps 4 and 5 a few times on normal beamed notes, it seems similar. I think the fourth grace note should be treated separate from the other three, but MuseScore may not be doing so.
Using MuseScore 2.0 Nightly Build (aeb28a7) - Mac 10.7.5.
Comments
About the improper presenting of beams, see this: #22671: Stems of grace notes protrude beam if quarter is present
Is it only grace note? If yes, priority -> minor
Yes, I think it applies to normal notes too.
Do you have a test case with normal notes?
Just use the original file?
There the problem is with grace notes, not with normal ones, right?
There the problem is with grace notes, not with normal ones, right?
Grace notes are used in the steps, but it covers both.
What's the expected behavior?
Actually, the note in the file is not really stemless. It is only visually stemless because the stem was simply made not visible.
At the moment, in the most recent revision ( f5cfb12dc5 ) if you click on the visually "stemless" note and select (the real) stemless in the inspector, the stem does not appear, as it is supposed to be (now it is a true stemless note). By unselecting stemless, the stem appears (as expected, since now it a "stemmed" note).
There is a strange layout for this file, see also #22671: Stems of grace notes protrude beam if quarter is present.
As said in #10, the current behavior should be the expected one (and the initial "stemless" was obtained without using the actual stemless option).
Windows 8.1 & Mac OS X 10.8.5, commit 4b1e86f
I am closing this bug report as fixed. Please re-open it if needed.
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.