playback broken, jumps incorrect, names of tocoda/coda change, frame around signs is altered randomly, volta positions are lost though automatic placement is off, end of song is not reached

• Dec 14, 2019 - 19:33
Reported version
3.3
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
duplicate
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
MuseScore

Use Segno/ToCoda/Coda (rename the labels): playback is incorrect 100% of the time (never jumps to segno)
Save and reopen: tocoda/coda labels are randomly changed
Turn automatic placement off on voltas and position manually, save and reopen: gives random placement in Y
Enter a score adding measures along the way: end of song is never reached
Put frames around segno/tocoda/coda/ etc, save and reopen: lines thicknesses randomly change (sometimes to 0), rectangles become squares randomly
Not playing back with the correct jumps makes the program unusable

Attachment Size
Assim_Mesmo (ms3).mscz 42.64 KB

Comments

• Dec 14, 2019 - 19:42
Title playback broken, jumpss incorrect, names of tocoda/coda change, frame around signs is altered randomly, volta positions are lost thought automatic placment is off, end of song si not reached ⇒ playback broken, jumps incorrect, names of tocoda/coda change, frame around signs is altered randomly, volta positions are lost thought automatic placment is off, end of song is not reached
Frequency Many ⇒ Once

Reply

• Dec 14, 2019 - 20:07
Severity S1 - Blocker ⇒ S3 - Major
Status active ⇒ by design

To Coda, Coda 1 and Coda 2 had wrong types (not To Coda or Coda) and names. The 2 2nd voltas were too long, they covered the jumps.

It surely is not a blocker, it doesn't prevent you from using MuseScore for its core usage: writing a score.

Attachment Size
Assim_Mesmo (ms3).mscz 39.51 KB

Reply

• Dec 15, 2019 - 10:45
Title playback broken, jumps incorrect, names of tocoda/coda change, frame around signs is altered randomly, volta positions are lost thought automatic placment is off, end of song is not reached ⇒ playback broken, jumpss incorrect, names of tocoda/coda change, frame around signs is altered randomly, volta positions are lost thought automatic placment is off, end of song si not reached
Frequency Once ⇒ Many
Severity S3 - Major ⇒ S1 - Blocker
Status by design ⇒ active

On trying to reproduce this, I noticed that when using the mouse while it is over the inspector, it may change values, even though the item in question is not selected. This may account for the unexpected changes in the frames around tocoda/coda et.
Still, the jumps (D.S. al Coda) do not work, which is the main issue.

Reply

• Dec 15, 2019 - 11:28
Title playback broken, jumpss incorrect, names of tocoda/coda change, frame around signs is altered randomly, volta positions are lost thought automatic placment is off, end of song si not reached ⇒ playback broken, jumps incorrect, names of tocoda/coda change, frame around signs is altered randomly, volta positions are lost though automatic placement is off, end of song is not reached
Frequency Many ⇒ Once
Severity S1 - Blocker ⇒ S3 - Major

Which in the current form of that score, is by design and not a blocker at all. And you're the first and only to report this, so Frequency is Once.
And please don't reintroduce mulktiple typos into the issue title...

These inadvertant changes of those jump markers' types though seems a bug indeed

Reply

• Dec 15, 2019 - 12:00
Title playback broken, jumps incorrect, names of tocoda/coda change, frame around signs is altered randomly, volta positions are lost though automatic placement is off, end of song is not reached ⇒ playback broken, jumpss incorrect, names of tocoda/coda change, frame around signs is altered randomly, volta positions are lost thought automatic placment is off, end of song si not reached
Frequency Once ⇒ Many
Severity S3 - Major ⇒ S1 - Blocker
Status duplicate ⇒ active

I've tried some experiments: exporting the xml, then opening the xml and start playback on that. All the jumps labels are changed, and additionally the last D.S. al Coda is changed to D.S. al Fine, even thought there is no Fine in the score. The playback now correctly handles the first D.S. al Coda. I changed the second one manually, and it at first played back correctly. After changing label-names and text, and saving the file, it failed again. After some more fiddling with names, all of a sudden it started working again. I attach the working file, because it may help you to figure out what the difference is between a working and a failing one.

Attachment Size
Assim_Mesmo (ms3-xml).mscz 37.89 KB

Reply

• Dec 15, 2019 - 12:02
Frequency Once ⇒ Many
Severity S3 - Major ⇒ S1 - Blocker
Status duplicate ⇒ active

And apologies for not having read your earlier replies

Reply

• Dec 15, 2019 - 12:20
Title playback broken, jumpss incorrect, names of tocoda/coda change, frame around signs is altered randomly, volta positions are lost thought automatic placment is off, end of song si not reached ⇒ playback broken, jumps incorrect, names of tocoda/coda change, frame around signs is altered randomly, volta positions are lost though automatic placement is off, end of song is not reached

Open a new issue for the XML ex- and import problem.

Reply