Playback not registering ties
Using Musescore 4.0.1.
The playback will always ignore ties and play a note even if it is tied. Have tried restarting, reinstalling, etc. Happens in all scores in all cases. Properties tab knows it is a tie and not a slur.
Comments
Score needed
In reply to Score needed by Jojo-Schmitz
First tie at bar 107
In reply to First tie at bar 107 by otiskenward
Confirmed. Best report this on GitHub
In reply to Confirmed. Best report this… by Jojo-Schmitz
Will do, thanks
In reply to Will do, thanks by otiskenward
I removed the "a tempo" at measure 102 and the ties played properly. Is this a score from a PDF or maybe from MS3?
In reply to I removed the "a tempo" at… by bobjp
If I remove the "a tempo" at measure 102, the tie in 102 is still not considered.
In reply to If I remove the "a tempo" at… by oMrSmith
Same for me now too. Here is what I originally did.
I created tied notes in measure 30. That tie worked. The one in 107 still did not. So I figured that something in between 30and 107 was the problem. So I started adding ties in measures 56, 89 94, and 97. Each time, the added ties worked but the one in 107 did not. I removed the dynamic in 102 and some other things that I don't remember for sure. Same result. Then I removed the a tempo and the 107 tie worked. I undid the removal and the tie did not work. I removed the a tempo again, and the tie worked.
So I must have done something else because just removing it now, indeed, does not work.
I think the point is that ties DO work in this score. But because it in an import from something else, there is something causing problems.
Hi! same issue but in a brand new file, not an Import musescore 3. Is there any kind of fix yet or no?
In reply to Hi! same issue but in a… by dvdvandyke
In general ties work fine. In order to understand why they don't in your score, we'd need you to attach it. Could be you are using slurs instead (a common mistake), could be a bug like the know issue with ties on distorted guitar, could be something else.
Hello,
I was having problems with ties when playback, then I realized that I should use the S shortcut for Slur, when the notes are different, but I should use the shortcut T for ties, this is when the notes are the same.
This is also applies to chords. That solve my playback issues.
In reply to Hello, I was having problems… by rceballo
Yes, slurs and ties are different things that look similar (but not identical). It is important to use the correct one for the intended effect. A slur covering notes of the same pitch can be useful sometimes; to indicate a soft rearticulation of a note for example. However I don't think Musescore's playback handles such subtleties.