In a 2.0 score, where a tie or slur direction has been changed away from 'Auto' (i.e. to 'Up' or 'Down'), these slurs/ties get read as Auto' in 3.0, a5a97ff, Windows 7
This bug still is in 5248e08.
It is not only a problem of loading, but it seems as if changed positions are not saved at all.
At least they have gone after saving and re-loading.
1. Make a new score with one line.
2. Input the notes c + d
3. Add a slur
4. Mark it and change the position with "x"
5. Save
6. Reload: The change is gone.
That is a different issue, which might be related. I'm currently not set to test with a muild from master, but here's a 2.2.1 score with user set ties and slurs (both set to below), do they stay there in master?
Comments
Similar issue reported here: Slurs have reverted to default settings .
sorry, seems mine actually was the duplicate of your #122486: Slurs have reverted to default settings.
This issue appears on last July 15.
This nightly works: bb5aa89
And not this one, beginning next day: 1dcfefd
After checking, I'd bet a small coin on the following commit of the first mentioned nightly above: https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/commit/2de4e0d3f9c567813a112358d…
.
and there most likely it is the 2nd change to libmscore/slur.cpp. The old code is probably a good candidate for being moved to libmscore/read206.cpp
See also #126896: Legato slurs are not changable, most probably a duplicate
Same for #128126: position of slurs is reset after saving and re-loading a file
This bug still is in 5248e08.
It is not only a problem of loading, but it seems as if changed positions are not saved at all.
At least they have gone after saving and re-loading.
1. Make a new score with one line.
2. Input the notes c + d
3. Add a slur
4. Mark it and change the position with "x"
5. Save
6. Reload: The change is gone.
Cannot reproduce. I add a slur, change the direction, save the file, close the file, open the file.
Result: the slur has the defined direction.
On a 2.x score with non-auto slurs direction settings, opened in current master?
Jojo, nope. Used 3.0 score to reproduce. It is seemed to be the case from the last comment...
That is a different issue, which might be related. I'm currently not set to test with a muild from master, but here's a 2.2.1 score with user set ties and slurs (both set to below), do they stay there in master?
In reply to That is a different issue,… by Jojo-Schmitz
Opened the file in 3.0:
![Screen Shot 2018-04-11 at 1.49.34 PM.png]( "Screen Shot 2018-04-11 at 1.49.34 PM.png")
Slurs are Down. Thank you for clarifications, Jojo!
Thanks for checking!
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.