Hairpins have shifted out of position
Win 7 / eb36276
File created in MS 2.0.3. The Hairpins have all shifted out of position in the nightly.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| hairpin_issue.mscz | 34 KB |
Win 7 / eb36276
File created in MS 2.0.3. The Hairpins have all shifted out of position in the nightly.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| hairpin_issue.mscz | 34 KB |
Comments
Probably related to #142176: All guitar barre lines have shifted out of position.
29d6140 / Win 7
For example, the long hairpin in measures 7-8 seems to have been shifted forward. See below:
2.0.3:
![hairpin_2.0.3.PNG]( "hairpin_2.0.3.PNG")
2.3.0 (nightly):
![hairpin_2.3.0.PNG]( "hairpin_2.3.0.PNG")
Probably another manifestation of a known issue where elements that have horizontal offsets applied in 2.0.03 somehow end up with vertical ones as well - see #143756: Lyrics manually adjusted in 2.0.3 shift vertical position in 3.0.
I have also encountered problems with hairpins like this. I have an MSCZ file which shows okay on my laptop. But when I upload the file to the Musescore website, the score is displayed with a number of the hairpins above other measures than the ones where I placed them. Moreover, when I start Musescore again on my laptop, I see that a lot of the hairpins in my local environment have changed too. I first have to select all hairpins in my score and change the horizontal position of the pins to: 0.00sp
For 2.x this got fixed, see #109021: Hairpin and other symbols are shifting when relayout occurs It might have broken again though, see also #187151: Hairpins shifting out of position on systems containing ties from stem
This issue here is about 3.0 though
There are a number of separate issues that lead to these wandering hairpin problems. Some are fixed in both 2.x and master, others in 2.x only, and at least one in neither. It will be important to keep this all straight.
Hairpins are corretly placed in terms of the description in this issue. But the source score has a lot of interesting elements which are not correctly processed now. I will create a separate issue for them. I hope you don't mind.
![hairpin_hor_shift.PNG]( "hairpin_hor_shift.PNG")
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.