Musicxml export - Slur between note and rest doesn't export
Reported version
3.0
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
closed
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
Hello,
I'm now transcribing this work into braille:
https://musescore.com/user/3797871/scores/5145647
The Musicxml file shows the left hand of bars 1 and 3 without slur on single note to a rest. I went into the Mscx code, found the slurs are actually here. So this is a bug that Musicxml can't export such very short slurs. Both version 2 and 3 of Musescore have this problem. Can this issue be solved? Thank you in advance!
Regards
Haipeng
Fix version
3.1.0
Comments
Related to #281511: [EPIC] Braille friendly musicxml export
Am investigating. At least in 2.3.2, the slurs in measure one's lower staff get exported to MusicXML as pedal lines, which is obviously incorrect.
My mistake, the pedal lines are in the score but set to invisible and I was running MuseScore with "show invisible" off. Still investigating.
Cause: the MusicXML exporter requires slurs to start and stop on notes. Shouldn't be hard to fix.
Yes, there are lots of hidden pedals, which are exported together with lots of other hidden objects into xml, and I have to use a python script to get rid of all such things from mscx before running the xml conversion.
yes, just add a slur element below the rest. Another dilemma is: should we work on such fixes on 2.3.2 or 3.0.3? Musescore 3 has many problems, even older Musescore files will have problems when opened in 3. There are no measure numbers in the 3 mscx file, and some system texts will be lost during the opening. Musicxml exported from 2.3.2 is much more complete than 3's.
There will be no more 2.x releases; all future development should be on the master / 3.0. Whatever problems there are in 3.0 export need to be addressed, for sure.
Solution known.
In reply to yes, just add a slur element… by hhpmusic
@hhpmusic, could you report separate issues in the issue tracker for the MusicXML export problems with MuseScore 3.x (for those that have not been reported already) ? Otherwise I may not be aware of them.
Dear Leon,
All the issues regarding Musicxml export were put here, and are related to Musescore 3. One of them, system texts, can be exported in Musescore 2's xml function, but all others are the same in Musescore 2 and 3.
https://musescore.org/en/node/281511
I submitted them as Musescore 3, not 2, as you can see.
Haipeng
Pull request #4900
Fixed in branch master, commit c594d12578
fix #284068 - Musicxml export - Slur between note and rest doesn't export
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.