Erratic behavoir when applying slur or haripin to a septuplets
In Musescore 2.02 habe ich eine 7-tole angelegt und wollte den 1. und den 7. Ton mit einem Bindebogen verbinden. Klicke ich zuerst den 1. und dann den 7. Ton an und dann den Bindebogen, geht der Bogen bis zum Ton NACH dem 7. Ton der 7-tole. Klicke ich zuerst den 7. Ton der 7-tole und dann den ersten an und DANN den Bindebogen, sitzt der Bogen vom 1. bis zum 7. Ton der 7-tole korrekt.
Crescendo- und Decrescendoschnäbel gehen bei 7-tolen IMMER einen Ton zu weit, egal, in welcher Reihenfolge man die Töne anklickt.
Das Problem scheint bei Triolen, 5-tolen und 6-tolen nicht aufzutreten.
Schönen Gruß,
Traugott
GIT commit: f51dc11
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Bugreport Vitz.mscz | 5.56 KB |
Comments
If you click the 1st note of the triplet, then click the last not, the last gets selected and the 1st deselected, then the slur goes from the selected (last) to the next note, this is by design
If you select the 1st note, then ctrl+select the last (list-select), then add the slur, it works.
Same if you select the last and then ctrl+select the first
Hairpins though don't seem to work that way, if you list-select the tuplet and then use add the hairpin, this goes from the 1st note of the triplet to the end of the measure, that much I'd consider a bug.
Also range select (click first note of tuplet, shift+click last note of tuplet) doesn't seem to work properly, the selection does include the next note and then consequently spans the slur bovver the whole range, it indeed works to select last and shift+select 1st.
Without fully understanding the original report, it seems related to #63041: 8va lines can't be reduced in septuplet. I think the fact that 480 (number of ticks in a quarter note) is not divisible by 7 creates some unique issue for septuplets.
This might explain the slur behavior, but not the hairpin behavior I think?
Hmm, well, maybe it does, I can't reproduce the 'up to the end of the measure' behavior reliably