Brackets do not appear after horizontal frame
Reported version
3.0
Priority
P1 - High
Type
Functional
Frequency
Many
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
closed
Regression
Yes
Workaround
No
Project
Insert a horizontal frame in a score (educational content) delete the brace between piano staves.
Attachment | Size |
---|---|
LM3 Examen 1er Trimestre.mscz | 15.7 KB |
Fix version
3.1.0
Comments
I cannot reproduce. Could you please describe the scenario (step by step, to which measure should I add the frame, what is the expected behaviour, what is current behaviour)? If you were able to record a gif, it would help a lot.
In reply to I cannot reproduce. Could… by Anatoly-os
Here is a screenshot of the behavior in MuseScore 2 compared to MuseScore 3
So it's not deleting a brace, it is merely not creating a new one after the horizontal frame?
This may have been deliberate; I know we don't treat this as a new system anymore in several respects. But obviously, we do reproduce the clef etc. If most people feel they want to see the brace repeated after the frame, we could certainly consider it. Might be best to ask on the for opinions on the Development forum.
In reply to So it's not deleting a brace… by Marc Sabatella
Okay Mark. Bug or feature, for me the result is the same. But I understand that it is a decision that does not correspond to me.
I guess you have to resort again to insert graphics to write something like an incipit
Or that this kind of examples for publications will require creating two files instead of just one as could be done in MuseScore 2.
In my modest opinion what would be better for everyone and for the software in particular is to be able to choose whether to show or not.
Sorry for the confusion
Thanks for the clarification. Obviously we would continue show them at the beginning of a system, horizontal rame or no, the question is only about what to do about mid-system breaks. For some purposes (like those you show), it's what you want; for others (like inserting stage instructions in an opera, say) it might not be. But, it's probably better to include them and then people can make them invisible if they don't want.
In reply to Thanks for the clarification… by Marc Sabatella
It's much easier to make an existing item invisible than to add a non existent item.
No guarantees, but this does seem worth addressing for initial release.
Thanks!
Came up again in https://musescore.org/en/node/281077
https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/4747
Came up again in https://musescore.org/en/node/287243
Fixed in branch master, commit 2f9d6e165b
fix #279417: Add brackets after HBox with *Create system header*
Fixed in branch master, commit b236a495d7
fix #279417: Address dmitrio95's code review
Fixed in branch master, commit 1598f89f21
_Merge pull request #4747 from tobik/279417-hbox-brackets
fix #279417: Add brackets after HBox with Create system header_
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.