Make tremolo between notes play correct rhythm when between tuplets
Type
Graphical (UI)
Severity
S5 - Suggestion
Status
closed
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
See discussion here: https://musescore.org/en/node/20261#comment-801251
To reproduce the issue:
- I used 4/4 time and created 2 consecutive 1/4 note triplets.
- Make one pitch a C and another a D (they can be any pitch).
- Put 32nd notes between tremolo (it can be any tremolo, that's what I used)
- To confirm it plays incorrectly on the next two beats put a C 1/4 note followed by a D 1/4 note with 32nd between notes tremolo
- Press play
Result: both tremolos play the same. This problem does not exist with single note tremolos in a tuplet - they play correctly.
Fix version
3.6.0
Comments
Are you still seeing this? I can't reproduce. Maybe I'm not understanding the instructions properly. You are talking about a measure twith two tuplets, a tremolo between the first two notes of the first tuplet, followed by another between the third note of that same tuplet and the first of the next? I tried this and it worked as expected - I'm actually surprised it worked, but it did:
In reply to Are you still seeing this? … by Marc Sabatella
I'm still seeing it. Try this to make it simple:
Create a score in 4/4 time.
In measure 1 put two half notes of different pitches and put a tremolo between two notes (I suggest using an 8th note tremolo since you can count the notes easier).
In measure 2 create a 6th-let (select the measure and press ctrl+6).
Make two dotted 1/2 notes and place the same tremolo line as in the first measure.
Press play.
Result: both measures play 8 8th notes (assuming you followed my suggestion)
Expected: the first measure plays 8 8th notes, the measure 2 should play 12 8th notes in the same time as measure 1 played 8.
For comparison's sake
In measure 3 create a whole note with a tremolo only on that note
In measure 4, create a 6th-let (select the measure and press ctrl+6 as before)
Make this a single dotted whole note and apply the same tremolo line as measure 3.
Result: If using 8th note tremolos you get 8 notes in measure 3 and 12 notes in measure 4. This is what is expected if the tremolo is on a single note or between 2 notes.
See attached score.
Tremolo problems.mscz
See PR:
https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/6838
Fixed in branch master, commit 8e5caa4909
fix #259771 : make tremolo between notes play correct rhythm when between tuplets
Fixed in branch master, commit 425136c355
_Merge pull request #6838 from AntonioBL/twonotetremoloplayback
fix #259771 : make tremolo between notes play correct rhythm when bet…_
Fixed in branch 3.x, commit 3b6c2064e8
fix #259771 : make tremolo between notes play correct rhythm when between tuplets
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.
In reply to (No subject) by Jojo-Schmitz
I'm sorry, but I don't understand if the problem is solved. (Don't understand the last messages of this thread.) Because I'm having the same problem with the playback, the triplet tremolo sound as a normal tremolo.
In reply to I'm sorry, but I don't… by franksab
Score needed...
In reply to Score needed... by Jojo-Schmitz
Here it is.
Score stems from MuseScore 3.4.2, the issue got fix in 3.6.0...