Chord with second placed too close to beginning of measure
Ubuntu 14.04, GIT commit: e523aad
Another one in the same spirit as #106726: Distance from barline to accidental is too small and #107131: Grace notes over or under the staff incorrect - this time, it is the "backnotes" in a chord containing seconds that is spaced incorrectly. It's noticeable (and incorrect according to Gould) for notes on the staff, but worse for notes above/below the staff, especially if barlines are drawn through the staves:
Comments
Fixed in branch master, commit b3cd356d60
fix #107221: chord with second placed too close to beginning of measure
see vtest layout-7
Actually, I'm a little confused by the vtest - the reference shows what appears to be the *old* behavior. But the score itself loads better. Still not really correct - chords with accidentals are too *far* from the barline. See also #106726: Distance from barline to accidental is too small - it seems we are now back to the original behavior there?
Yes, the reference is the old rendering so its easy to see what has changed. The distance between barline and notes is static and the "barNoteDistance" style parameter (1.2sp). In the UI the parameter is called "Note left margin".
Maybe the desired layout can be achieved by defining two values: the minimum distance between barline and notehead (left edge of note head) and a minimum gap between barline and left edge of the ChordRest Segment shape (note + possible accidental + gracenotes etc.).
The result would be a gap which gets smaller if there are accidentals.
Yes, I think this makes sense.
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.