Order in item lists, e.g. Palettes, Master Palette, Style, appear random

• May 11, 2018 - 14:02
Reported version
3.0
Type
Graphical (UI)
Frequency
Few
Severity
S5 - Suggestion
Status
active
Regression
No
Workaround
Yes
Project

The order in lists, e.g., Palettes, appears random and is difficult to search. Suggest using alphabetical order. For example, change from: Grace Notes, Clefs, Key Signatures, Time Signatures, Barlines, Lines, ... Change to: Barlines, Clefs, Grace Notes, Key Signatures, Lines, Time Signatures, etc.


Comments

Won't work in other languages, so we would end up with different orders depending on language or same order, but no longer alphabeticaly sorted in other languages. Has been discussed before.

The current order has some logic to it, actually, but only some, and not one that is obvious or relevant to everyone. I would definitely like to see additional thought given to this. But I agree, the alphabet is not my first choice either. The palette containing arpeggios and glissandos, for instance, belongs in the same logically whether called "arpeggios and glissandos" or "glissandos and arpeggios"

Isn't this issue partially fixed for palettes with the new system?

However, menus order (like "style") remain strange to me. Is there some logic there?

Frequency Few
Regression No
Reported version 3.0
Workaround No

I actually agree that the default order can have more logic, but if we do this change, users accustomed to the present order may complain, me also included ;-)

But personally I still prefer optimizing it.