After deleting first note in tie, second note has incorrect pitch
1. Open attached score.
2. Select the last crotchet in the first bar.
3. Delete.
4. Click on the first crotchet of the second bar.
Result: B♭ sounds, despite there being no flat, or key signature.
Discussion: Generally, I'm not sure if after step 3, the first crotchet of the second bar should be either B♭, or B natural.
It's likely to be connected to #1395: Accidental after a tied note, but I consider this different - it's a sound issue, rather than visual one.
Using MuseScore 1.1 and 2.0 Nightly Build (4685) - Mac 10.6.8.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Tied Accidental.mscz | 1.45 KB |
Comments
To elaborate on this, if you try to move the second note after you deleted the first one by click and up/down arrow, the note doesn't move.
Confirmed - 1.1. Thanks.
It's fine on the nightly build trunk though (4691).
proposed fix for this:
https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/276
This issue seem to be stuck since quite while, is the pull request not good enough?
Or doesn't apply any more?
The issue is still pending; it is mostly a visual think, though, as the remaining note gets it due accidental once another operation triggers a global re-layout; the display is also correct if the score is saved and re-open.
As for #21234: Naturals appear for notes that would have been an accidental of previous key signature after undo transpose, as the score data are all correct and the display ultimately corrects by itself, it has probably a low priority: I wonder if it would be the case to mark the issue as minor.
The pull request cannot be merged anymore (the code base changed too much); probably it can be updated to the current code base, though.
M.
so that PR should be closed?
I wasn't thinking correctly (sorry!), but I filed another, perhaps better report: #23538: Deleting first note in tie over bar displays no accidental for second note